Agreement is one of the most difficult aspects of English to master. It’s human nature (just think of Judge Judy or any of the various and assorted “reality” shows): people don’t like to agree.
Well, let’s all be New Agey and become one with our inner conflicts, or some such nonsense. Today we’re talking about subject-verb agreement. It’s gonna be one big peace fest.
In a sentence, the subject and the verb must always, always agree in number (and tense, but that’s another post). The kittens, for example, are playing with the yarn. Sarah and John are putting their skis on.
It’s easy enough in present tense. I know that especially around where I live, past tense gets to be a little tricky. The kittens was playing with the yarn. Not correct. Not at all. “Was” is a singular verb, and “kittens” is a plural subject.
Sarah and John might be a little bit sneakier. When speaking, it would feel natural to say something along the lines of, “Sarah and John’s putting on their skis.” But this stretches out to, “Sarah and John is putting on their skis,” and we all know that doesn’t sound natural at all because Sarah and John are two separate people.
One must be cautious in discerning subject-verb agreement, however, because it can try to trip one up. The store called Steve and Barry’s are not anything. Steve and Barry’s is something because it is one entity. Just think back to your Power Rangers days. The Zords are plural. They fight the giant monsters separately. But when they join up to form the Magazord, they become one entity, even though it’s made up of five or six zords. The Magazord is singular, like Steve and Barry’s. Sarah and John, however, do not form a super robot that can destroy an entire cardboard city in mere moments. They remain separate from one another, and are therefore plural.
Another tricky one is a word like band. It is, believe it or not, correct to say, “The band are tuning their instruments,” because each individual band member is tuning his own separate instrument. Conversely, the band is playing a song, because one song is being played by one uniform group. It’s another shape shifter in the terrifying complexities of the English language.
That’s enough of that for now. Right now, we’re moving on to the main course.
In writing a formal paper, it is often difficult to convey a neutral gender when one is attempting to form an argument or to make a point. One is not allowed to use “you” and write in the second person, so one must be forced to make a choice. One may utilize the word “one” and use it every time one needs a pronoun, but it tends to become grating to one’s nerves.
I have nothing against using “one,” of course, because I like it; I use it often, but not exclusively. The other choice for the writer of the paper is simply to choose a gender and stick with it. In a politically correct world, a person may often blanch at using one gender in an argument or paper. He may think it will make him sound sexist, but when it comes down to it, he really has no other choice. He could keep using “one,” but that’s tedious. And he can’t keep using “he or she” because repetitive use of that phrase is against the rules (it’s also tedious). But instead of turning to one gender sentences, his first thought it to go where?
Their.
No, not there.
Because the English Language has no word for a person of unknown or neutral gender, people often turn to they and their in order to convey the fact that they don’t know the gender of a person because they and their are gender neutral. The problem is the fact that these words are plural, and they’re being used in a singular manner. That’s not done.
We all do it. If you’re sitting in a classroom and someone in the hallway starts screaming bloody murder, you turn to your cohort and you say, “Heavens to Betsy, who is that in the hallway? I say, they’re screaming bloody murder!” Or something like that. Because you don’t know what gender that screaming person is.
You can usually get away with it in speech, because speech goes by so fast people don’t even notice it (unless it’s a glaring mistake, like “The kittens was playing with the yarn”). In writing, however, your they’re is there for all to see forever and ever, amen. So you can’t use it.
Therefore, when in doubt, pick a gender so that your subject and verb agree, and stick with it. I promise you won’t sound sexist, unless you actually are being sexist, and then I can’t help you.